Skip to main content
WithMarsha app iconWithMarsha
How it worksWhy MarshaFor TherapistsLearn DBTBlogPricing
Download WithMarsha on the App StoreGet WithMarsha on Google Play
How it worksWhy MarshaFor TherapistsLearn DBTBlogPricing
Download WithMarsha on the App StoreGet WithMarsha on Google Play
Back to skills library
WithMarsha app icon
Emotion Regulation

Pros & Cons of Changing Emotions

Pros and Cons of Changing Emotions is a worksheet for weighing the benefits and costs of regulating an emotion or leaving it unchanged.

Export PDF

Opens a dedicated export document in a new tab, then launches the PDF dialog.

Quick answer

What this DBT worksheet helps you do

Pros and Cons of Changing Emotions is a worksheet for weighing the benefits and costs of regulating an emotion or leaving it unchanged.

Reviewed July 16, 2026 under WithMarsha editorial standards. Educational DBT practice only; not therapy, diagnosis, treatment planning, or crisis care.

How to practice it

Move through each step slowly. Notice what the skill asks for and how you can experiment in real life.

1

Name the Emotion & Urge

Specify the emotion you are feeling, its intensity (0–10), and the action urge it creates.

2

Pros of Changing the Emotion

List short- and long-term benefits of regulating—more control, better relationships, aligned behavior.

3

Cons of Changing the Emotion

Note the effort, discomfort, or perceived losses involved in using skills.

4

Pros of Not Changing

Capture any payoff from keeping the emotion (e.g., motivation, protection, communication).

5

Cons of Not Changing

Record the costs of letting the emotion run unchecked—impulsive actions, burnout, damaged trust.

Real-world examples

Try spotting moments like these in your week. Notice how the skill changes the ripple effect of a tough situation.

Anger at a teammate

Emotion: anger (8/10). Pros of changing: stay professional, find solutions. Cons: takes time to cool down. Pros of not changing: express hurt. Cons: explode in meeting, damage collaboration. Decision: use TIP skills, set up calm conversation.

Sadness after rejection

Pros of changing: re-engage with friends, get things done. Cons: feels invalidating to move on too fast. Pros of not changing: honor the loss. Cons: risk isolating. Decision: allow sadness tonight, plan opposite action tomorrow.

Practice Activity

Complete the grid for an emotion you faced today. Decide whether to regulate, ride it out, or blend strategies.

What emotion/urge are you evaluating?

What are the strongest pros/cons of changing it?

What are the strongest pros/cons of staying with it?

What choice feels most effective right now?

Clarify whether you want to change the feeling or the behavior

An emotion, its intensity, and its action urge are related but different. You may want to keep concern about an important issue while reducing the urge to attack someone. Write which part you are considering changing. “Stop caring” is different from “respond without shouting.”

List the perceived benefits of keeping the emotion honestly. Anger may feel protective or motivating. Worry may feel like preparation. These experiences are worth understanding even if the current pattern is costly. The worksheet becomes less useful when you deny every reason the pattern persists.

Then compare immediate and longer-term costs. Rehearsing an argument may feel energizing now while taking time from the action you actually need. Avoid assuming that reducing intensity means approving a wrong or abandoning a goal. You can retain a value while changing how you act on it.

Worked example: holding on to anger about a boundary

Imagine that someone used your belongings without asking. Your anger points to a real boundary concern. The short-term pro of staying angry is that it keeps the issue in mind. The costs might include repeatedly drafting insults and losing time to replaying the event.

The pros of regulating intensity include making a clear request and choosing a consequence you can maintain. A perceived con is fear that becoming calmer will make you give in. Write that fear explicitly. You can then plan a boundary statement before regulating, so the concern remains visible.

Your chosen action is to draft a specific request with DEAR MAN and decide what you will do if the behavior repeats. Regulation supports delivering the message. It does not erase the fact that the boundary was crossed or require the other person to agree with your account.

Look for hidden all-or-nothing choices

“If I stop worrying, I will be careless” offers only two extremes. Ask whether there is a middle option, such as scheduled preparation followed by returning to another task. “If I feel less guilty, I will not repair the mistake” may overlook the possibility of making the repair directly.

Do not force yourself to change an emotion because someone else dislikes it. The decision should account for your goals, values, safety, and the facts. Another person's discomfort does not automatically establish that your feeling is the problem.

End with a behavior you can review

Choose a next action linked to the analysis. You might gather facts, solve a practical issue, communicate a boundary, or practice allowing an emotion without acting on an urge. Record what you expect the action to help with, then review the actual result.

Use Check the Facts for interpretation questions and Mindfulness of Current Emotions when allowing the feeling is the main task. If emotional changes are severe, persistent, or connected to danger, seek qualified support. A worksheet can clarify ambivalence about practice; it cannot determine what treatment you need or require you to suppress a justified response to harm.

Want to practice emotion regulation with the WithMarsha app?

WithMarsha guides you through this skill in real time, keeps track of your practice, and helps you build your DBT toolkit day by day.

Download WithMarsha on the App StoreGet WithMarsha on Google Play
WithMarsha app iconWithMarsha

Your AI-powered DBT skills companion. Learn and practice evidence-based skills at your own pace.

Product

  • How It Works
  • Pricing
  • About the Founder
  • For Therapists
  • Resources Hub

Learn

  • About DBT
  • DBT Skills Library
  • DBT Evidence
  • Editorial Standards
  • Blog
  • Crisis Resources

Compare

  • Best DBT App
  • WithMarsha vs DBT-Mind
  • WithMarsha vs DBT Coach
  • DBT App vs Worksheets
  • DBT App vs Journaling
  • WithMarsha vs DBT Groups

Use Cases

  • DBT App for Daily Practice
  • DBT Homework App
  • DBT Diary Card App
  • DBT App for Anxiety
  • DBT App for BPD

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Disclaimer
  • Support

WithMarsha is inspired by the work of Dr. Marsha Linehan, creator of Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), but is not affiliated with or endorsed by her or the Linehan Institute.

WithMarsha is not therapy and is not a substitute for professional mental health care. If you're in crisis, call 988.

© 2026 GTM Bot Inc. All rights reserved.