Skip to main content
WithMarsha app iconWithMarsha
How it worksWhy MarshaFor TherapistsLearn DBTBlogPricing
Download WithMarsha on the App StoreGet WithMarsha on Google Play
How it worksWhy MarshaFor TherapistsLearn DBTBlogPricing
Download WithMarsha on the App StoreGet WithMarsha on Google Play
Back to skills library
WithMarsha app icon
Distress Tolerance

Pros & Cons of Acting vs. Not Acting

Pros and Cons is a DBT distress-tolerance skill for weighing the short- and long-term consequences of acting on an urge or resisting it.

Export PDF

Opens a dedicated export document in a new tab, then launches the PDF dialog.

Quick answer

What this DBT worksheet helps you do

Pros and Cons is a DBT distress-tolerance skill for weighing the short- and long-term consequences of acting on an urge or resisting it.

Reviewed July 16, 2026 under WithMarsha editorial standards. Educational DBT practice only; not therapy, diagnosis, treatment planning, or crisis care.

How to practice it

Move through each step slowly. Notice what the skill asks for and how you can experiment in real life.

1

Define the urge or behavior

Name the action you are tempted to take (texting an ex, quitting your job, self-harm, skipping therapy).

2

List short-term pros and cons of acting

Be honest about the relief or payoff—and the immediate fallout—you’d experience if you follow through.

3

List long-term pros and cons of acting

Look past the first few hours. How would acting affect your goals, relationships, self-respect, or stability next week or next year?

4

List pros and cons of NOT acting

Identify the discomfort you’d sit with if you resist, and the long-term wins you get from staying on track.

Real-world examples

Try spotting moments like these in your week. Notice how the skill changes the ripple effect of a tough situation.

You want to ghost a friend after a misunderstanding. Short-term pros: avoid awkward talk. Short-term cons: anxiety about messages. Long-term pros of ghosting: none. Long-term cons: lose a solid friendship. Pros of not ghosting: repair a good relationship; cons: uncomfortable conversation. You decide the discomfort is worth the long-term trust.

You’re tempted to binge eat. Acting gives short-term numbness but long-term shame and health setbacks. Not acting brings short-term agitation but long-term confidence in your goals. You choose to text a DBT buddy instead.

Practice Activity

Fill in the matrix for an urge you experience often. Keep it handy so you can review when the urge appears.

What urge or behavior are you analyzing?

Short-term pros of acting? Short-term cons?

Long-term pros of acting? Long-term cons?

Short-term pros of NOT acting? Long-term pros?

Name the action before comparing its consequences

Choose one behavior you are considering. “Do something about this” is too broad. “Send the angry message tonight” identifies a decision. Then compare acting on the urge with not acting on it, including both immediate and later consequences.

Be honest about the short-term payoff. A reactive message may feel relieving or create a sense of being heard. Pretending there is no payoff makes the worksheet less useful. The point is to see that payoff alongside other consequences, not shame yourself for wanting relief.

Also name the discomfort of not acting. Waiting may leave uncertainty, anger, or an unfinished conversation. A realistic plan includes how you will handle that interval. “Do not send” becomes more workable when paired with a safe coping option and a specific time to reconsider the issue.

Worked example: quitting during a difficult afternoon

Imagine wanting to resign immediately after a frustrating meeting. The short-term pros of sending the resignation might include relief and a feeling of control. Immediate cons might include an unanswered practical question about income or benefits. Longer-term consequences depend on circumstances you need to check, not assume.

For not acting immediately, a short-term con is staying with discomfort. A possible pro is time to gather information, discuss options, or prepare a more deliberate decision. Not acting tonight does not mean agreeing to stay forever. It means preserving a decision until you can evaluate it more fully.

You choose a temporary plan: save the draft without sending it, review financial information, and speak with an appropriate support person. If the workplace is unsafe, the relevant options and urgency change. The worksheet should reflect those facts rather than make delay an automatic rule.

Weigh importance instead of counting bullet points

A list with more pros is not necessarily the better option. One serious consequence may matter more than several small benefits. Mark uncertainty, likelihood, and importance where useful, without inventing precise probabilities. You can identify which missing information would change the decision.

Separate another person's possible reaction from established consequences. “They might be angry” is a prediction unless you have specific evidence. At the same time, do not minimize a credible threat. The worksheet supports judgment; it cannot make a dangerous situation safe through balanced-looking columns.

Choose a next step and a review point

End with an action you can take now: pause, ask a factual question, gather information, or contact support. If you postpone the main decision, state when you will return to it. Otherwise, postponement can become indefinite avoidance.

Use STOP for a pause and ACCEPTS for a temporary distraction while an urge passes. If the behavior involves self-harm, violence, or immediate danger, do not weigh safety as an ordinary preference decision. Seek immediate human help through appropriate crisis resources. This is an educational decision aid, not a risk assessment or a requirement to manage dangerous urges alone.

Keep going with related DBT guidance

Use this worksheet as a starting point, then connect it to a deeper explainer or a higher-level skill hub.

Review the DBT skills hub

Want to practice distress tolerance with the WithMarsha app?

WithMarsha guides you through this skill in real time, keeps track of your practice, and helps you build your DBT toolkit day by day.

Download WithMarsha on the App StoreGet WithMarsha on Google Play
WithMarsha app iconWithMarsha

Your AI-powered DBT skills companion. Learn and practice evidence-based skills at your own pace.

Product

  • How It Works
  • Pricing
  • About the Founder
  • For Therapists
  • Resources Hub

Learn

  • About DBT
  • DBT Skills Library
  • DBT Evidence
  • Editorial Standards
  • Blog
  • Crisis Resources

Compare

  • Best DBT App
  • WithMarsha vs DBT-Mind
  • WithMarsha vs DBT Coach
  • DBT App vs Worksheets
  • DBT App vs Journaling
  • WithMarsha vs DBT Groups

Use Cases

  • DBT App for Daily Practice
  • DBT Homework App
  • DBT Diary Card App
  • DBT App for Anxiety
  • DBT App for BPD

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Disclaimer
  • Support

WithMarsha is inspired by the work of Dr. Marsha Linehan, creator of Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), but is not affiliated with or endorsed by her or the Linehan Institute.

WithMarsha is not therapy and is not a substitute for professional mental health care. If you're in crisis, call 988.

© 2026 GTM Bot Inc. All rights reserved.